Protecting sight, expanding capacity: The independent sector’s role in building a sustainable NHS eyecare service
Operational challenges
Approaches to commissioning elective care have varied considerably across the country, including during the post-COVID recovery period. The introduction of enhanced activity management provisions for commissioners in April 2025 has added a further dimension to these local differences. While some areas actively support patient choice and make full use of the capacity available across NHS and independent providers, others have adopted more restrictive approaches, including administrative requirements, limitations on referral routes and mandatory minimum waiting times. This creates a fragmented picture nationally, with patients’ ability to exercise choice and access timely care increasingly dependent on where they live.
For providers who operate across multiple locations around the country, the fragmented structure of commissioning across different Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) is a significant challenge.
Where providers face differing referral criteria, service specifications, or funding arrangements in neighbouring systems, overall system efficiency is impacted. For example, it can lead to a situation where there is a long waiting list of patients in one area but no commissioned funding to treat them, while in another area funding is available, but there are insufficient referrals to utilise that capacity. As a result, access to treatment is increasingly experienced as a postcode lottery, with patients facing very different waiting times depending on where they live.
Alongside variations in commissioning, there remain differences in how NHS systems make use of independent sector capacity. Despite more than two decades of collaboration and national policy supporting partnerships to reduce waiting times, local financial and operational pressures can influence referral decisions, with some systems prioritising activity within NHS trusts rather than making full use of capacity across all available providers. While these pressures are understandable, they can have unintended consequences for patient choice and access to timely treatment. A more consistent approach, focused on making the best use of capacity across both NHS and independent providers, would help maximise the number of patients treated and accelerate progress in reducing waiting times.
A further challenge is ensuring that commissioning arrangements accurately reflect patient demand for services. In many areas, annual contracts do not fully account for the level of activity required, with the 2025/26 contractual arrangements making this increasingly significant for service planning. Greater alignment between demand, commissioning and capacity is essential to maintaining sustainable services. Healthcare providers need sufficient certainty to plan their workforce, facilities and investment, and significant short-term fluctuations in commissioned activity can undermine this. More predictable, longer-term commissioning arrangements would help protect existing capacity, support future investment and ensure patients can continue to access timely care.
A more recent development is an increased focus on the use of Single Points of Access (SPOAs) in managing patient pathways. Integrating SPOAs successfully into eyecare pathways must be managed carefully. Community optometrists already face a complex referral pathway – many optometrists are unable to access the NHS e-Referral Service directly, and while we understand funding to address this will shortly be forthcoming, it currently presents a significant challenge where referrals must go through intermediary digital platforms before reaching the chosen provider. This adds an additional administrative step into the patient pathway and introduces multiple points where issues can occur, including technical failures, missing or delayed referrals, or patients not being directed to the provider they originally selected.
Enabling optometrists to consistently refer directly through the NHS e-Referral Service will streamline the pathway, reduce delays and administrative burden, improve patient choice, and generate significant financial savings for the NHS by removing unnecessary layers in the referral process.
Single Points of Access (SPOAs)
Managed well, Single Points of Access (SPOAs) can improve patient pathways by providing consistent clinical triage, helping patients reach the right service at the right time, and supporting informed choice of provider. They can also improve referral quality, avoid unnecessary hospital appointments and make better use of community capacity.
SPOAs are already used across a number of NHS specialties, with many delivering these benefits. However, members also report examples where they have shifted referral patterns between providers rather than reducing referrals across the system, and in some cases made it harder for patients to exercise choice.